Why am I writing a review on an anime that's already almost 2 years old? Because its too good. And also because I just read three reviews from people who absolutely thought that this anime sucked. They... are in the minority, and I seriously wonder what they consider good anime. At least they had the decency to say that FMP was good. But whatever, I don't care about them. Anyway, here is my review.
Baccano! is awesome, funny, and gets really complicated. Its written very much like Pulp Fiction-style, or as I thought, Robert Cormier style. While I absolutely hate Robert Cormier's books (After the First Death left a very bad impression, and I refused to try I am the Cheese), I absolutely loved Baccano!
Story: The storyline of this anime was set up in such a way that you actually have to think in order to know what the hell is going on. There are three separate times in this story that range from 1930-1932. Each year has its own storyline, and, if I remember correctly, sometimes there are more than one story going on in a year. One episode, however, is set in 1711. So yeah, the story can get really confusing. Surprisingly, I totally did not mind at all. The writing in this story is quite amazing. The first episode might blow your brains out, but if you continue watching, everything gets pieced together.
So the question is, what exactly is this story about? Hahaha, that's a really hard question. It has immortals, mafias, alchemists, and normal, of seemingly normal people. What I view as the "main" storyline, and also my favorite, would be the one with the train, the Flying Pussyfoot (yes, engrish, but its been worse). Why? Because every other storyline seems to be explaining the one on the train. So, the story with the Flying Pussyfoot is about...
three different groups with completely different goals who want to hijack a train, and the adventures of our lovely and idiotic "main" couple, Isaac and Miria, the adorably precocious Czeslaw, of Czes-kun for short, and the ominous Rail Tracer. I absolutely love the scene where the three groups all barge into the dining car in order to take over; I felt so bad for the passengers. As for the three groups, one is led by the homicidal maniac, Ladd, who is simply there to kill for fun and hopefully get some money, another is led by the mute and lovely Chane and her companions who are there to take the train hostage in order to release their beloved leader, Huey, from jail, and finally there is my favorite group that has the most focus. This is the only group where all the members on the train from this group were actually fully introduced. The leader is crybaby, adorable Jacuzzi Splot (yes, I did have a WTF moment there, though his name sounds better when they pronounce it), his bomb-loving lady is Nice (I love her seiyuu, BTW), the ridiculously enormous guy, Donnie (no seriously, its hilarious when he's trying to walk through the train), and Nick (Despite the fact that I do like his character, I couldn't really think of a nice, short description). This group's motive is simply to steal some bomb from the back of the train, not kill. So basically, the other two groups have their own bloody war in and on the train, while everyone else gets involved. Really, I am amazed at the dexterity of these people. Since when were trains so easy to fight and run on? But still, they were some awesome fight scenes.
The other storylines... my second favorite would be the one involving how the characters became immortal, and how the characters all tied in together. The "main" character for this one would probably be Firo. I love Firo. Not only is he adorable, he is also a really cool fighter, and gets a pairing. He just joins the mafia in the beginning of the story, and is great friends with many others, even ones not in his family. The two most significant friends are Luck Gandor, of the Gandor family, and Maiza, of Firo's family. Maiza has his own storyline, but I'll stop talking about it here.
Then there's the storyline with Eva and her brother Dallas. It... was probably my least favorite, but it was alright and did relate to the story. It did show more about the mafia families than the other stories, and Luck Gandor had a bigger part in it. Luck Gandor was probably that character in the anime who if he was real, I wouldn't mind marrying jkjk but really...(he's not young at all and he's a mafia leader, I know, but he's so suave, charismatic, and charming).
There are other storylines, and the all interweave with each other. If I had to rate the entire anime's storyline from 1 to 10, 1 being the worst, 10 being the best, I'd say it would be 8.5.
Characters: The thing that stand out the most about Baccano! is how many characters there are. In the opening alone, they show 17 of the characters that have been deemed "main characters". Thing is, the did miss out many other important characters, so that brings the count to at least 25. Of course there are the side characters as well, so the actual cast just continues to grow. Normally, you wouldn't think that any anime could build up 25 characters satisfyingly, but Baccano! manages to do it, and in only 13 episodes. Of there are a few characters, like the quiet, stoic, probably masochistic Lua. She remains a complete mystery for the entire series, and even the OVA does not mention her. It's such a pity since she seemed like such an interesting character.
For the first time ever watching an anime, I didn't have one character that I despised. Even though I tend to hate stupid characters, the idiots Isaac and Miria didn't bother me at all. In fact, I loved their antics. Maybe thats because for once, characters don't get hurt because of their stupidity,and that's the couple's charm point. Also, none of the girls were annoyingly weak or had to constantly protected. Okay, there was Eva, but she wasn't really stu- okay so she made a stupid mistake in an episode, but it was not so bad that I disliked her.
My rating for the characters would be 9/10.
Art/Design: The art for this anime was pretty good. It wasn't terrible, it wasn't OMG AMAZING (I haven't seen many that were like that). The quality was nice, the action scenes were nicely done. I'd have to say, though, I thought the art for Chane and Nice outshone the art of the males. Being a girl, I guess that's something big. I'm sorry, but they looked so pretty. The art in this series gave me a different, and more realistic feel than the other series out there, and it suited it well.
My rating for the art and design would be 9.5/10. Okay, so it may be a little high, but I LOVED the sequences where the immortal characters healed, or came back to life. And the train scenes.
Sound: Probably the best I've heard. While Joe Hisaishi is still the best composer, the jazzy tunes in this anime completely suited the story. The music is noticeable, but in a good way. It doesn't distract you from the scene, but it leaves an impression on you whether you were really listening to the music or not.
As for the seiyuus, they did an amazing job. What made me laugh was when I recognized both Isaac's and Nice's voices. At first I was worried that I was watching too much anime, but the I realized I only watched one anime series of each voice actor. Suitably enough, stupid Isaac's voice actor was the same as the rowdy, not so equally stupid, Momo-sempai from Prince of Tennis. Nice's voice actor did the ninja Sarutobi? from Gintama. The masochistic one in love with Gintoki.
That was hilarious.
My rating for the music would be 9/10. The voice acting would 9.5/10.
Overall: This anime was probably the best anime I had ever seen. Period. I usually don't watch anime because they tend to fall short of expectations or die out toward the end (Darker than Black), but I thought this anime was amazing. I wouldn't mind reading the manga if I have time for it, but I don't think that anyone's really scanlating it (its unfortunately not popular). Anyway I highly recommend this anime to those who don't mind bloody things. I really hope there's a sequel.
My rating for this entire anime would be 9.2/10.
If my ratings don't add up to the overall, its because I decided to lower it a bit for some weird reasons.